Logging contractor sustainability review completed

January 28, 2019

By: The Working Forest Staff

BC — As a result of the final phase of the logging contractor sustainability review, the ministry will amend the Timber Harvesting Contract and Subcontract Regulation to make forest-sector contractors and licensees more sustainable and competitive in the long term.

Amending the regulation is the recommendation of former provincial premier Dan Miller, who facilitated the last phase of the review.

“This review was done to make sure logging contractors’ paycheques accurately reflect the work they do and their cost of doing business, while also keeping licensees competitive,” said Doug Donaldson, Minister of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development. “By implementing Mr. Miller’s recommendations, logging contractors and their families in communities ranging from Port Alberni and Nanaimo, to Kamloops, Williams Lake, and Nakusp, will be better able to count on a stable income to pay their mortgages, put food on the table and repair or replace aging or worn equipment. I’d like to thank Mr. Miller and George Abbott before him, for their work to create a more-unified B.C. forest sector.”

The multi-phase logging contractor sustainability review was launched by the ministry in January 2017 to improve the overall competitiveness of logging contractors and licensees by finding commonalities and encouraging improved and respectful business relationships.

The initial phase consisted of an economic assessment and review of the contracting sector to develop baseline information and identify economic drivers within the sector.

Former provincial cabinet minister George Abbott and his partners in Circle Square Solutions were contracted to consult with contractors and licensees to define issues. They combined the findings with the economic assessment to produce possible recommendations that would result in both enhanced sustainability and competitiveness for both contractors and licensees.

In the final phase, Miller facilitated conversations between contractors and licensees to identify where there was consensus on the recommendations and then make final recommendations for implementation.

Miller largely found that the most financially sustainable top 25% of contractors and licensees already engaged in some level of information sharing, mutual planning, and negotiated rate models. Consequently, he has recommended amendments to the Timber Harvesting Contract and Subcontract Regulation to:

  • improve transparency by requiring the parties to jointly develop rate models;
  • improve work predictability and mutual recognition of changed circumstances where rates can be reassessed;
  • establish a timely and effective arbitration process based on the rate model; and
  • require mandatory data collection to improve access to information.

In addition, to help ensure that all parties are instituting practices that lead to mutual sustainability, Miller recommends developing a best-practices guide.

“As allowable annual cut levels decline and forest-sector economics shift, it is ever more critical that contractors and licensees – being codependent in the B.C. forest sector – find ways to work together to improve competitiveness,” said Miller. “My final recommendations focus on creating a sustainable environment where a diverse range of contractors and licensees – large and small, single and multi-phase – can survive and thrive in the long term.”

Ministry staff will engage contractors and licensees on regulation amendments later this year.

“Today’s announcement is what we were hoping for and will result in a fundamental change in the relationship between contractors and their employers. These are very positive regulatory changes, and the recommendations will have a significant impact on timber harvesting contractors across B.C., and their future ability to be sustainable, said David Elstone, executive director, Truck Loggers Association.” 

“We asked for a sustainability review of the logging contractor sector to ensure logging contractors have sustainable rates that will allow them to remain in business and help the sector to be competitive and efficient. Jointly developed rate models and an arbitration structure that is based on sound information will help provide peace of mind for logging contractors looking to get a fair shake for the work they do,” adds Randy Spence, chairman, Interior Logging Association.

“We welcome the conclusion of the logging contractor sustainability review and the recommendations made by Dan Miller and George Abbott before him. We look forward to the full Implementation of the recommendations, including increased access to information and jointly developing rate models based on best practices. We recognize that there still remains much work to implement the recommendations of the reports that are vital to the financial health of our contractors and the communities in which they live and work. We wish to thank Dan Miller and his group for their efforts,” said Trevor Jobb, president, NorthWest Loggers Association.

“Contractors and licensees share an important relationship in the forest sector. As with all relationships, there are issues that arise that need to be addressed. The contractor sustainability review has provided a forum to explore opportunities to make improvements that support the overall sustainability of contractors, licensees and the industry as a whole. While there is still more work to do, we are generally supportive of the recommendations that are emerging. We are encouraged by the common desire by all parties to increase transparency and accuracy of data so that contractors and licensees can be sure that rates are both appropriate and competitive. We would like to thank Dan Miller for facilitating a thoughtful and productive process, and we look forward to continuing to work together in the months ahead,” said Susan Yurkovich, president, and chief executive officer, BC Council of Forest Industries.

“The ILMA members see the contracting community as a very important and integral part of our business. Our members have always worked with our contractors to ensure we maintain a sustainable working relationship, as the strength of one is dependent on the strength of the other. We are optimistic that these proposed changes will help improve and strengthen our industry moving forward,” said Dan Battistella, president, Interior Lumber Manufacturers’ Association (ILMA).

Learn More:

Timber Harvesting Contract and Subcontract Regulation: 

Your comments.

  1. Bernie Stockermans says:

    This is great news for BC logging contractors. We have the same problem with logging rates and the sustainability of the logging industry here in Ontario. It would be a good time for the Ontario forest industry, provincial government and logging associations to push for similar solutions here.

  2. George Delisle says:

    I think there is another party that is missing from the equation. As long as government can raise taxes at will, such as the carbon tax, that contribute to a less competitive work force compared to other countries we will be on shaky ground. The government needs to come up with a rebate system similar to the GST program to level the playing field if we want to compete on the world stage. cheers George Delisle.

Your #1 source for forestry and forest industry news.

Built by Sofa Communications